BombDiggity Start a conversation

How to Ask Better Questions as a Leader: Humble Inquiry and the 5 I’s of Communication

Two colleagues talk at a small round table, one listening closely while the other speaks, with a red question mark between them

Asking better questions is the leadership practice of moving from telling to asking: inviting the other person’s thinking before you offer your own. MIT’s Edgar Schein called it humble inquiry. In Human Centered Leadership it is the last of the 5 I’s of Communication, and it is how leaders gather better information, share authority and make room for their teams to learn and create.

Most leaders were promoted for having answers, so asking can feel like a step backward. It isn’t. This guide covers why leaders drift into telling, what humble inquiry is, the five communication capacities that lead up to a powerful question, how a Casual Learning Conversation works, and three questions you can try with your team this week.

Key takeaways

  • Leadership roles train people to have answers, and over time that crowds out the habit of asking. Teams respond by deferring, waiting and holding back their real thinking.
  • Edgar Schein described the shift from telling to asking as humble inquiry: wanting to understand someone else’s experience before offering your own.
  • The 5 I’s of Communication (Immersion, Investigation, Imagination, Imitation and Inquiry) build on each other. Inquiry, the powerful question followed by full listening, is where they come together.
  • Good questions activate the other person’s thinking, signal real interest and spread authority across the team instead of concentrating it in the leader.
  • A Casual Learning Conversation has one goal, curiosity. No review, no status update, no challenge to solve.

Why do leaders stop asking questions?

Here is a pattern that shows up in almost every struggling team we’ve worked with: the leader talks more than they listen.

It rarely starts that way. Leadership roles reward people for knowing things, deciding quickly and having the answer ready. Over time, that conditioning crowds out the habit of asking. The leader’s expertise expands to fill all the available space, and the team adjusts around it.

What the team learns is to defer, to wait and to undercontribute. These are capable people. They have simply stopped bringing their real thinking, because experience has taught them the leader will supply the answer anyway. The cost doesn’t show up on a dashboard. It shows up as ideas nobody raises and early warnings nobody sends.

What is humble inquiry?

Edgar Schein, the MIT professor who was one of the most influential organizational psychologists of the past century, saw the move from telling to asking as the most important shift a leader can make. He called the alternative to telling humble inquiry: the desire to understand someone else’s experience before offering your own.

Schein found that this shift changes the relational dynamic of leadership entirely. When the leader asks first, the conversation stops being a transfer of instructions and becomes a shared look at what is actually going on. With that change comes something larger: the organization’s capacity to learn and adapt.

What are the 5 I’s of Communication?

Human Centered Leadership treats communication as a practice of connection and discovery, more than a way to transmit information. At the center of that practice are the 5 I’s of Communication: five progressive capacities that together make up relational intelligence in leadership. Each one builds on the one before it.

1. Immersion is deep observation. It means paying close attention to what is actually happening around you: what’s said and what isn’t, the energy in a room, the dynamic beneath the words. Leaders who practice immersion notice what no meeting agenda will surface.

2. Investigation is disciplined curiosity, the authentic desire to understand another person’s experience before offering your own. Teresa Amabile and Steven Kramer’s research on inner work life found that everyday support from leaders, including respect, encouragement and real interest in people’s work, shapes how people feel about that work from one day to the next. People can tell when curiosity is performed and when it’s real.

3. Imagination is perspective-taking: the mental effort to inhabit someone else’s frame. It asks you to set your own frame aside for a moment and see the situation as the other person actually sees it.

4. Imitation is behavioral alignment, the subtle mirroring of pace, posture and tone that says “I am with you” without words. Leaders who do this naturally build stronger relationships faster and earn trust more quickly.

5. Inquiry is where it all comes together: the disciplined practice of asking powerful questions, then fully listening to what comes back without formulating your response.

What do good questions actually do for a team?

Questions do something statements can’t. A statement closes a line of thinking; a good question opens one. When a leader asks well, four things happen at once:

  • They activate the responder’s thinking rather than closing it down.
  • They signal real interest in the person and their work.
  • They distribute authority rather than concentrating it in the leader.
  • They model intellectual humility, which research links to organizational learning, creativity and better decisions.

In A More Beautiful Question, Warren Berger documents how the most innovative companies share one practice: they ask better questions before they start solving. Asking the right question is the first act of creative work.

A leader who shifts from telling to asking does more than gather better information. They change what’s possible in every conversation they join.

Telling vs. asking: how do the two leadership habits compare?

The difference between a telling leader and an asking leader is easiest to see side by side. This summary draws on the research and practices above.

What changesLeading by tellingLeading by asking
Where the thinking happensMostly in the leader’s headAcross the whole team
Where authority sitsConcentrated in the leaderDistributed to the people closest to the work
What the team learns to doDefer, wait and undercontributeBring their real thinking, including what’s unfinished
What the leader hearsWhat people think the leader wants to hearWhat’s happening below the waterline
Effect on learning and creativityThe organization repeats what it already knowsBetter questions come before better solutions
What it signals“My expertise fills this space”“Your experience matters and I want to understand it”

What are the signs you’re telling more than asking?

Most leaders who over-tell don’t notice it. These signs, drawn from the pattern described above, are a useful self-check:

  • Your team waits for you to speak first in meetings, and rarely builds on each other’s ideas without you.
  • People bring you updates and finished work, but seldom questions, half-formed ideas or early concerns.
  • You find yourself planning your reply while the other person is still talking.
  • Most of your one-on-ones are status updates or performance conversations, with little room for anything else.
  • You learn about challenges late, often after they have become a crisis.
  • When you do ask a question, people look for the “right” answer instead of telling you what they think.
  • Your curiosity has started to feel like a routine step in the conversation rather than something you mean.

What is a Casual Learning Conversation?

One of the most valuable and most underused communication practices in Human Centered Leadership is what we call the Casual Learning Conversation: a non-threatening, exploratory dialogue where the leader’s only goal is curiosity.

There is no performance review, no status update and no challenge to solve. The leader simply takes real interest in how a person is experiencing their work, what they’re learning, what’s blocking them, and what they’re noticing that the leader might not be.

Organizations known for creative output have long made room for this kind of talk. From Bell Labs to Pixar’s deliberately designed campus, they built in space for unscripted, curious conversation. Leaders can’t engineer every one of these conversations, but they can cultivate them by making it a habit to be curious rather than perpetually busy.

How do you hold a Casual Learning Conversation?

The practice is simple to describe and harder to do well, mainly because it asks you to resist the urge to fix things. These steps put the 5 I’s to work in a single conversation:

  1. Choose a moment with no agenda attached. Keep it separate from reviews, status meetings and decisions, so the person knows nothing is being evaluated.
  2. Arrive paying attention (Immersion). Notice the person’s energy and what might sit beneath their words before you say anything.
  3. Pick one open question. Use one of the three below, or another that invites the person’s experience rather than a report.
  4. Ask it, then stop. Resist the follow-up, the example or the reassurance. Let the silence do its work.
  5. Listen fully (Inquiry). Don’t formulate your response while they’re talking. Stay with what they’re saying until they’re done.
  6. Follow with curiosity, not solutions (Investigation and Imagination). Ask what that’s like for them, or what they’d want, before offering your own view.
  7. Let what you hear change something. The conversation only counts if it informs how you lead afterward.

Which three questions should leaders try this week?

You don’t need a long list. Start with one of these three.

“What’s the most interesting problem you’re working on right now?” It almost always produces answers you didn’t expect, and it lets the person choose what matters to them.

“What’s something you’re seeing that you think we should be paying more attention to?” It gives people permission to surface what typically stays below the waterline: the early signals, quiet risks and missed opportunities they have noticed but not said.

“What would make your work more meaningful to you?” It connects to intrinsic motivation and almost always reveals something actionable that no engagement survey would have caught.

Ask one. Then stop. Listen fully, without formulating your response, until the other person is done.

How does asking better questions fit Human Centered Leadership and the Creative Alliances System™?

Human Centered Leadership starts from the idea that leadership is relational: people do their best thinking when the relationships around them make it safe and worthwhile to contribute. Asking better questions is one of the most direct ways a leader builds those relationships day to day.

In our Creative Alliances System™, questions touch all three parts of how a team works:

  • Bonds. Humble inquiry strengthens the Creative Climate and the Collaborative Partnerships around the Core Conditions, because people learn that their experience is wanted.
  • Tasks & Tools. The 5 I’s and the Casual Learning Conversation are practical tools a leader can use in any meeting or one-on-one.
  • Goals. Questions such as “What would make your work more meaningful to you?” keep the team’s sense of purpose in view, not only the next deliverable.

Questions also sit close to the other Human Centered Leadership practices we write about. Being approachable, available and askable makes people willing to answer honestly, and the empathy behind feeling connected at work is what keeps curiosity from feeling performed.

Frequently asked questions

How do you ask better questions as a leader?

Start by asking before telling. Choose open questions that invite the other person’s experience, ask one at a time, then stop and listen fully without planning your reply until they’ve finished.

What is humble inquiry in leadership?

Humble inquiry is Edgar Schein’s term for the desire to understand someone else’s experience before offering your own. It shifts a leader from telling to asking, which changes the relationship and the organization’s capacity to learn and adapt.

What are the 5 I’s of Communication?

The 5 I’s of Communication in Human Centered Leadership are Immersion (deep observation), Investigation (disciplined curiosity), Imagination (perspective-taking), Imitation (behavioral alignment) and Inquiry (asking powerful questions and listening fully). Each capacity builds on the one before it.

Why don’t leaders ask more questions?

Leadership roles train people to have answers, and over time that conditioning crowds out the habit of asking. The leader’s expertise fills the available space, and the team learns to wait for answers instead of offering its own.

What is the difference between a Casual Learning Conversation and a one-on-one?

A typical one-on-one often covers status, performance or a specific challenge. A Casual Learning Conversation has none of those: the leader’s only goal is curiosity about how the person is experiencing their work, what they’re learning and what they’re noticing.

What are good questions to ask your team?

Three that work well are “What’s the most interesting problem you’re working on right now?”, “What’s something you’re seeing that you think we should be paying more attention to?” and “What would make your work more meaningful to you?”

How do better questions help creativity and innovation?

Warren Berger’s A More Beautiful Question documents how innovative companies ask better questions before they start solving. Asking the right question is the first act of creative work, so leaders who ask well open the door to better ideas.

What you hear when you ask will likely change something about how you lead, if you let it.

— Lane & Jules
Morris & Morris | BOMBDIGGITY, LLC

Michael Lane Morris, PhD and Jules Morris, PhD are co-authors of “Human Centered Leadership: The Decisive Leadership Advantage,” published in the SAGE Handbook of Human Resource Development (2024).

Sources & further reading

  • Amabile, T. M., & Kramer, S. J. (2011). The progress principle: Using small wins to ignite joy, engagement, and creativity at work. Harvard Business Review Press.
  • Berger, W. (2014). A more beautiful question: The power of inquiry to spark breakthrough ideas. Bloomsbury.
  • Schein, E. H. (2013). Humble inquiry: The gentle art of asking instead of telling. Berrett-Koehler.

This article is part of our Human Centered Leadership hub, where we collect our work on how leaders build trust, connection and creative capacity in their teams.

Filed under , , , , , , ,